Initially the trade is subject, lets look at the comparison:
Warner 30 TDs last season
Jackson 7 TDs 1273 total yards in only 11 games
Peterson 10 TDs 1760 ry 125 py
Brady 50 TDs in 07
Drew 14 TDs 824 ry 565 py
Lynch 9 TDs 1336 total yards
lets also examine Chris Johnson
10 TDs over 1400 total yards.
Peterson trumps Brady, Lynch and Jackson Trump each other because Lynch will miss three games this season and Jackson has a history of being injured at some point. This leaves Warner and Drew as the real decision makers of this trade. Drew is being hyped at the number 1 back this season, we disagree. Jacksonville has never been an all run and no pass offense, his numbers last year will probably increase only in touchdowns. But then again that can be good for you. He will still get a ton of catches as a back and with catches comes yards. As for Warner, he will not outstat Brady, but he will provide consistency from week to week with TDs and Yardage points.
If you can get him to substitute Johnson for Jackson then we say you may want to pull the trigger on this deal. Johnson had a very nice rookie campaign, but this year stewart has battled early injury woes and the titans no longer have the running QB they once had. This means more production for a workhorse like Johnson without the injury chances of Jackson.
You have the 2nd best receiver in the league with Wayne. Johnson is getting older and isnt as consistent as Wayne and Smith is in that same boat. Plus Carolina has a really brutal 2nd half schedule so we dont recommend taking anyone from that team. Calvin still plays for Detroit who doesnt have a set QB yet and has to play Minn twice, packers twice, and the Bears twice, all teams that like to crush them
Now if Johnson is not part of the deal its a tough call, consider these decision points:
Brady will throw 35+ TDs, but he also has a new RB core that can take some pressure off of the passing game, but at the same time, the addition of Galloway only help an already elite WR core.
Lynch is suspended for three games, and Buffalo has an impressive rookie in the wings waiting for his chance to claim the starting job, but also do not forget that with TO and Lee Evans as the wideouts, the running game will have a chance to perform undefended and this could mean big things for Lynch when he returns.
Jackson hasnt started more than 12 games in two years and the rams offense is terrible as is their defense. There arent as bad as the lions but if you stop Jackson and stop Avery you stop the entire team. But Jackson has proven that even with injurys and a horrible supporting cast he still produces. His problem is he doesnt produce week to week, which is when you need a RB most.
A.P. just became the number 1 back thanks to Favre. With Favre behind center the pass will need to be defended which opens up big things for Peterson. He also gets to play Detroit twice and the Bears twice, both teams he destroys each time he plays them.
Drew will get you consistent points week to week and so will Warner. There is no downside to either of these players that we can see. They may not get you Brady and AP numbers, but sometimes 16 good games is better in fantasy that 9 huge games.
From a keeper prospective Brady, Drew, and Lynch are all young players. They will be playing a lot longer than Warner and Jackson. This is why Johnson entices us to pull the trigger, his career just began.
Overall it seems like this other owner is trying to dump age and trying to recruit youth. He is trying to bait you with AP and its not a bad tactic. But Brady has at least 5 years left in him, Warner has maybe 2. Drew just became the premiere back on his team and until we see him in a full season without taylor, his explosive potential is too much to give up. Jackson is good but age and team make him a huge risk. Lynch is good but off-field troubles are never a good thing to have especially with Buffalo has other weapons to use.
If you want our answer, we would not pull the trigger. With Johnson instead of Jackson, its really up to who your backup QB is for the future is. Having AP and Johnson would be great, but then again so can Drew and Lynch. If after a few weeks of play he is willing to make this deal then mention that to him. Until we see what Drew can do on his own, and what Brady plans to do with his new offense, its too risky of a move.
UPDATE: Brady 28 TDs. Warner 26 TDs (then he retired)
Jackson 4 TDs, 7-100 yard games. Drew 15 TDs 5-100 yard games.
Peterson 18 TDs 3-100 yard games (One against the Lions). Lynch 2 TDs, 0-100 yard games.
Brady and Drew outscored the other three players combined in Fantasy for the year.